Most downloaded would go to a members who have not been around in years.
Anything else would be very subjective and would probably only cause problems. People throw fits about ratings and rankings. How do you think they would react to not getting an award they think they deserve or someone else getting an award they think is undeserved?
Its seems like a good idea on the surface, but play it out in your head. I doubt it would have positive effects.
we could all vote but people would be stupid and cheat with diff usernames. so immature. but they could log the IP. I know tons of peope would throw pissy parties and stuff but if it was just the mature ones.
put it as a poll, the adminds make those up anyways right? so just have "which do you think is the best visual style of the year" or whatever catagory, and list a few of the more popular ones, someone would have to be really starved for attention to bother making a bunch of logins just to give themselves extra votes.